What never fails to surprise me is how innocently DNA surprises begin. In this episode, we hear from Doe – yes, thatās a pseudonym – who uncovered her DNA surprise in 2021.
A skillful genealogist, Doe bought a DNA test for her husband, who was curious about his family history. As it just so happened, she purchased the test during a buy one, get one free sale, so she decided to take a test herself. When she received her results, she learned that not only was her birth certificate father not her biological father, but that the story sheād always believed about her mother was false.
In this episode, she shares how the discovery and the continued secrecy have affected her, and how she uses her experience to help others.
Thank you for sharing your story, Doe.
Thanks again to Doe for sharing her story and be on the lookout for her podcast, Decoded: Secrets of the Family.
Join the DNA Surprises Patreon community! Listen to ad-free episodes one week early, gain access to exclusive content, use merch discounts, and more.
Episode Transcript
Transcripts are AI-generated and may not reflect the final published episodes.
[00:00:00] Doe: I also was, I was scared for my mother because she, you know, told me, if your father finds this out, he will disown you and divorce me.
[00:00:09] Doe: This is the reason they got married 50 years ago, was because she told him I was his child. So he married her because he was, quote, doing the right thing. Probably not the thing you want to find out after 50 years of marriage, almost, at that point, that you didn’t need to do that. You spent your life in a marriage that you did not need to be in.
[00:00:33] Doe: And, you know, of course, like any marriage, it had its ups and downs, more downs than ups. They were young and didn’t really know each other and got married for the wrong reasons. And somehow were able to sustain it for public consumption for a long time. And so her expectation of me was that I would continue to you know, play the game.
[00:00:52] Doe: Be the good girl and not say anything.
[00:01:02] Doe: My name is Doe. I use the pseudonym to protect my identity. I’m 53 years old and I live in Tucson, Arizona. I was born and raised in upstate New York.
[00:01:14] Doe: Well, my surprise story goes back to 2021. When I discovered my DNA surprise, which was in August of that year but prior to that starting back in childhood I am the daughter of a 17 year old high school senior. She she herself was raised by a single mother and found herself pregnant with me.
[00:01:36] Doe: She was sure she knew who my biological father was and she notified him that she was pregnant with his child. He proceeded to leave town and he was gone for about two and a half years. with no one hearing from him. And during that time, I lived with my teenage mother and her mother who was about my age at the time when I was born, and they both helped together to raise me for the first three years of my life.
[00:02:03] Doe: The man that my mother notified was my father, he returned when I was about two and a half years old. And from pressure from his family they were a very Catholic family there was pressure to do the right thing. And so he more or less said, Hey, maybe we should do the right thing and get married.
[00:02:20] Doe: Very romantic. So, so at 20 and 22, they were married in the spring of 1973. A year later, they had bought their first home in a small town in upstate where I grew up and lived my childhood, my teenage years, graduated from high school. My father and I really never had a relationship with one another.
[00:02:41] Doe: He comes from an abusive background and really had no idea how to relate to a child, since no one had ever really related to him. So it was a very contentious, stressful, abusive upbringing in a lot of ways. And with a mother who was, young and had no real sense of her own self or power to try to defend me against it.
[00:03:02] Doe: So I got out of that town and the house. As soon as I could I went to school in New York I went on to get married, had two children. The marriage did not work out and my children and I moved from upstate New York to southern Arizona in the year 2000. I went to nursing school and re educated myself and became an RN working here in town since 2007. And that’s sort of where my ball starts rolling, is I have been at my job for many, many years. One of my colleagues who works on the same floor as I do came to me one day and was talking to me about the fact that she had just celebrated her 65th birthday, and that she had been adopted as a 30 day old infant from a home for unwed mothers in Richmond, Virginia in 1956, and that she had done a DNA test to see if she could find family members.
[00:03:55] Doe: She had heard a rumor that I was a genealogist. That was something I had done as a hobby. Shortly after having my first child, I was interested in where I came from and what I was contributing to my child genetically and ethnically and culturally. And so I had started not knowing a thing and self taught.
[00:04:14] Doe: So, it had been quite a while. I was pretty skilled at the genealogy aspect of, what she was looking for. The DNA aspect, not so much. The DNA portion, like in nursing school, was rather limited. So it was going to take a bit more of a deep dive for me
[00:04:29] Doe: to
[00:04:30] Alexis: so you were just interested in family history. Your interest in genealogy had nothing to do with suspicions that you might have had.
[00:04:40] Doe: Correct. My father in law at the time, he was an avid, amateur genealogist. And he was sort of sharing his finds with me regarding his side of the family. And so when my children had such a complete picture of who they were genetically and genealogically, on one side of their family, I was hoping to provide for mine as well.
[00:05:03] Doe: So that’s where my interest in genealogy came up, was to sort of fill in that gap for my children. And I just really loved it.
[00:05:09] Alexis: Okay, so, going back over to your colleague. She’s wanting to do some digging into her adoptive, or not her adoptive, her birth parents. Okay.
[00:05:22] Doe: She’d been raised in a wonderful family with an older brother and two parents who she’d had Just this amazing life. Her parents had passed, and she was interested in finding out where she came from. Sort of that primal need to know where you come from. So I offered to help her.
[00:05:39] Doe: And I said I would do the best I could to try to help her figure it out. She had some paperwork from her adoption, which she graciously let me look through and read over. It took me about two weeks. To figure out how DNA and genealogy go together and using Ancestry. com, I was able to identify her parents by the end of the two weeks.
[00:05:59] Doe: And her father had passed away but her mother was still living and was in Baltimore, Maryland. And I was able to provide her with her mother’s address and telephone number. When I gave her the information, I said, you know, The thing I want you to think about is that there’s a lot of ethical issues that come with finding out this information.
[00:06:19] Doe: You know, your mother wished to be anonymous. She did not provide her name. She did not provide any breadcrumbs which might have allowed you to figure out who she was without needing to go to sort of these, you know, great lengths to figure it out. So just know when you’re thinking about reaching out, know that you could get rejected because she’s been hiding this secret for 65 years.
[00:06:43] Doe: And you’re just not sure where this might lead. So she chewed on it for a little while, but she did ultimately call her mother. They spoke on the phone, and she told her who she thought she was, and her mother did verify that I was correct, that she was my colleague’s biological mother. And there was a rejection there.
[00:07:01] Doe: She had gone on to marry and have four other children, and no one knew that she had given birth to this child in 1956 in Virginia. Yeah.
[00:07:11] Alexis: okay.
[00:07:12] Doe: asked that it stay that way. She did not have a desire to bring her daughter into her life and near use her. So then, of course, now my colleague and friend is dealing with the fallout from that.
[00:07:24] Doe: But she did have a very good experience with her paternal side. They welcomed her with open arms. She’s been to Virginia several times to see them. And has just been was eternally grateful to me. And it was a really wonderful feeling to be able to help someone figure out who they were and to see a more or less a really good experience for her. So after that my husband, he wasn’t my husband at the time, but he is now at the time he had said to me, Why don’t you do a tree for me?
[00:07:52] Doe: Just out of curiosity. I’d like to see what you can come up with. Okay, sure. So I took what I knew and started putting a tree together for him. And I pretty quickly discovered that his father’s father was an illegitimate child. So, he had taken on his mother’s last name and there was no birth certificate for him, no, like, christening records, nothing.
[00:08:17] Doe: He was born in 1897 in Arkansas, and in the mid 40s, He had filled out a delayed birth certificate to allow him to be eligible for Social Security. And on the delayed birth certificate, when asked if his birth was legitimate or not, it said no.
[00:08:37] Alexis: Oh, wow. Okay, so
[00:08:39] Doe: So
[00:08:39] Alexis: going to stop. I want to stop you there because I didn’t realize that this was something that was documented. The illegitimate versus legitimate. That’s actually on paperwork.
[00:08:51] Doe: It is on his actual delayed birth certificate form, yes.
[00:08:56] Alexis: Okay. And so this is your husband’s grandfather.
[00:08:58] Doe: Correct.
[00:08:59] Alexis: Okay. Okay.
[00:09:01] Doe: And of course he passed on in 1976. And my husband’s father passed in 2011. Correct. So anyone that would have had any possible information to give us was gone at that point, with me being able to ask the questions to get to the bottom of it. And so when I presented my husband with my findings and he said, How do I figure out who my great grandfather was?
[00:09:26] Doe: And I said, well, you’re going to have to do DNA. I, I have no way of figuring this out without having that tool to help us narrow it down, he has, your grandfather could be anyone. He wasn’t sure he wanted to do it. So he chewed on it for a while. And in May of 2021 I had seen on Ancestry that they were running a buy one get one for the upcoming Father’s Day holiday for their DNA test kits.
[00:09:55] Doe: And so I bought one, got one free got it in the mail and I gave it to him for Father’s Day. And I said, I will do it with you for moral support if you would like to. And he said, okay, let’s do it. So in June of 2021, we both spit in tubes, and we packaged them up and sent them off. About four weeks later, I get a text message that my DNA results are in.
[00:10:18] Doe: And mine actually came in ahead of his. And so I excitedly sat down to my computer. I, I had a couple of brick walls in my genealogy research. Especially on my father’s side that I was having trouble breaking through and other people in the family had also had trouble breaking through some of these brick walls.
[00:10:38] Doe: And so my thought here was, I’m going to get these answers. This is going to be great. I’m going to be able to bust through those walls and get some answers. So I logged into my results and I have this extensive list of people that I’ve matched to. The very first person, my closest match, is a person, I recognized the name right away.
[00:10:58] Doe: She’s a cousin of mine through my mother. And so, Ancestry. com has this option where you can choose one of your DNA matches, you can select a button called shared matches, and it will show you all of the matches you have in common with this person. So knowing this was a maternal match, I knew everyone I shared with this match would be my mother’s family.
[00:11:22] Doe: So I noted that on all of those people, and then I went back into the program and I asked to click on my paternal side. Let me show, see my paternal DNA. And my question was, who the hell are all these people?
[00:11:37] Alexis: Mm
[00:11:38] Doe: I don’t recognize any of these names. My closest match was a person that I had never heard of before.
[00:11:45] Doe: And so, I was sort of confused, I guess. It wasn’t really a surprise yet. I was more confused than anything. That must be something went wrong. That’d be weird though, because my maternal DNA is matching correctly.
[00:12:01] Doe: And I didn’t really know much about the process of how the DNA is extracted and how it’s tested.
[00:12:06] Doe: So I started doing my homework about the process of how the DNA is extracted and tested and how the matching works and all of those things, just to be able to see, is there something here that I might have fallen through a crack? This mine is incorrect.
[00:12:21] Alexis: Oh, yes. The, the infamous mental gymnastics. Yes. I also, I concluded that 50 percent of my DNA was incorrect. Somehow the lab messed up. That was my
[00:12:35] Doe: And isn’t it interesting that that is our go to because How could this be? This, this cannot be right. So, you know, why in the world would my, you know, mother tell me something that wasn’t true?
[00:12:48] Alexis: So you did not recognize any of the people, you didn’t recognize the name or anything like that,
[00:12:54] Doe: no, none of it. There was no one on my paternal DNA matches that I recognized. so, the story that my mother had always told me was that the, when she got pregnant with me, she lost her virginity. So I grew up believing that you know, gee, mom, that’s awful. Like I felt really bad for her. You lost your virginity, got pregnant.
[00:13:16] Doe: Like that is so rough. Oh gosh, mom, that’s awful. And so I was coming into it with that being my knowledge base. So it literally was impossible for anyone other than this man to be my father. And why would my mother tell me something that wasn’t true? So what I did then was I, I started to look at my top matches and I’m trying to figure out a way using my genealogy, my new information for genetics and DNA, and how am I going to figure this out?
[00:13:50] Doe: So I took my top 20 paternal matches. And I figured out how they were all related to each other using my genealogy skills. Using databases online, Ancestry. com, Facebook, you name it, I was using it. And so I was identifying these people and identifying their relationship to one another. There was one person on my match list that I had reached out to and said, Hey, Ancestry says we’re related.
[00:14:15] Doe: Do you have any clue how? And she said, No, I did my DNA because my father is adopted. Okay. And I was hoping to find his family for him by doing my DNA. And I said, well, your father and I are related through my paternal line, apparently. So I was trying to grasp at any straw, who can give me any information about who you are so that, you know, maybe I can figure this out.
[00:14:44] Doe: My next thought process was that maybe my grandfather isn’t who I think he is. Maybe my father is the person whose DNA is not correct.
[00:14:57] Doe: So I sort of went down that rabbit hole briefly and then sort of backtracked. No, that’s, that probably isn’t likely. And so there was one day in the beginning of September, I would say of 2021, I’m sitting at my computer and I’m looking at this, at the Excel spreadsheet and the family tree and all of the work I had done to figure out all of this.
[00:15:20] Doe: And. My husband says to me so anything new? And I said, no, I, I’m so confused. I just don’t even know, I’m not sure what I’m looking at anymore. I don’t know where I fit in all of this. It just doesn’t make any sense. And he said, if this were someone else’s DNA, what would you tell them? And I paused for a very long time and said with a very shaking voice, I would tell them that the man they think is their father is not their father, and he just put his hand on my shoulder and let me cry.
[00:15:55] Alexis: Up until that point, had it even crossed your mind or had you fully pushed it out until he asked you that question?
[00:16:05] Doe: I think I fully pushed it out. I was not willing to even entertain the idea. But he has a way of bringing things into focus for me when I’m having trouble. Figuring out which direction I’m going in. And he broke it down to the very simplest, simplest common denominator. Take yourself out of the equation.
[00:16:24] Doe: Now what do you think?
[00:16:26] Alexis: Yeah, that was a good question to ask and kind of bring things into focus. So I’m so sorry. That is devastating to realize, especially you’ve been doing all this research trying to make it make sense in a different way. What do you do once you realize that this is the case? Yeah,
[00:16:54] Doe: of get my feet back under me. What I really felt initially was I was angry at my mother. It was the very first thing I felt. I felt cheated and I felt manipulated and I, I was going through all sorts of scenarios in my head. How could this be? Given what I knew, what I thought I knew to be true about my conception how can this even be possible?
[00:17:19] Doe: Then I started to, to really sort of get scared because I was still trying to protect my mother subconsciously, I think. I started to think maybe I was, This is the result of an assault, and that she had tried to keep it quiet. You know, this is, you know, obviously, culturally, this is a problem in our society that women are the victims of sexual violence, and are not believed.
[00:17:47] Doe: And at the time I was born, absolutely not would she have been able to tell anyone anything like that, and would she have been believed. So my thoughts then sort of turned to really devastation for her. What if this is what has happened? And boy, you know, this woman raised me, the child of violence.
[00:18:07] Doe: And I was going down all of these, this rabbit hole with this as well. So I knew that I was not ready to talk to my mother about this and to ask the big question, which was who is my biological father after a few days? That’s right. Immediately where I went to the thing that I felt most grateful for through this whole process was I had the skillset to figure out who my father was.
[00:18:33] Alexis: truly,
[00:18:34] Doe: myself, when I removed myself from the picture and just sort of looked at myself as a client, that I was going to help figure out where they come from things started to fall into place pretty quickly then, once I put on my genealogy hat and took off my NPE hat. And I was able to figure out who my biological father is pretty quickly.
[00:18:58] Doe: I found a picture of him online, his high school yearbook photo, which I look exactly like. He has a daughter that’s five years younger than me, who could be my twin. When people see the photograph of her, they think it’s me. I also have a half brother who’s 11 months younger than me. And what I discovered was that my biological father was engaged to be married at the time of my conception.
[00:19:25] Doe: He is also seven years older than my mother. was underage at the time of my conception and so what I knew was that I was On his side, at least, I was the product of going outside of our relationship., Then the last part of the puzzle was how. I knew who, I knew where, I knew when, I didn’t know how.
[00:19:49] Doe: And I really needed to know. And it was a real struggle to try to find the words to talk to my mother about it. I was terrified she was going to disown me. That she was going to you know, be terrified that I had figured it out. I had found out her long held secret, which could just blow everything up.
[00:20:10] Doe: So I took about three months to really sort of put it all together in my head. And I eventually ended up sending my mother a text message. Because I just could not find the words to, to tell her what I had discovered and what does all this mean? I’m trying to figure out what’s, how this happened.
[00:20:33] Alexis: How did you have the patience to wait for three months. I hear on this podcast all the time, kind of varying timelines, right? There’s the people who, as soon as they open their tests, they’re calling their moms, wanting to know. Myself included. And then, and then there’s people who have waited like a year before asking their parents anything and kind of just sitting with it.
[00:21:00] Alexis: How did you find the patience to wait, especially with this detective, you know, genetic genealogist side of you, how did you hold off and have patience?
[00:21:12] Doe: I think it had a lot to do with my fear of what it would do to my relationship with my mother.
[00:21:17] Doe: And I knew I wanted to, I wanted, I needed to be in a place where Where I was going to be, I guess, okay with her severing our relationship. If that was going to happen, as a result of me confronting her with this.
[00:21:34] Doe: As I mentioned before, it was a very dysfunctional childhood that I came up through. So, I, what I realized through this journey is, I never really had a good grasp on who either one of my parents were. They were very good at hiding who they were from me as, You know, personal and on the inside people and so I really truly thought she would disown me over this because whatever it had happened, she clearly was trying to keep this a secret and I was about to out her and I needed to do it in a way hopefully that would try to preserve something of my relationship with her.
[00:22:08] Doe: Cause I really felt at that point, well, I know who my biological father is, but he I don’t know if he knows I exist and, or now I know about him, but no relationship with him at all. The man that raised me is not my biological father and I’ve never had a relationship with him. And now the relationship with my mother is on the table
[00:22:29] Alexis: Yeah.
[00:22:30] Doe: So I needed to put myself in a place where I was okay. I like to say I was okay being orphaned
[00:22:39] Alexis: Mm hmm.
[00:22:40] Doe: because I felt like that’s where this might be heading. And so I really needed to have a lot of internal conversation with myself about how much did I need to know the truth? Was it worth potentially losing my mother from my life over this?
[00:22:56] Doe: And after about three months or so of really struggling with it, I decided I needed to know. And so I composed a rather long text message. And it essentially, you know, said, I have something I need to tell you, I, and I don’t know how, so I’m doing it here. I’d prefer to do it to your face, but we don’t live near one another, and it just didn’t seem like anything to do over the phone either because I wasn’t sure who she might be with when I called, would she be in a place to talk about it?
[00:23:28] Doe: So I decided this was my best option and I sort of spelled it out for her what happened and I randomly took a DNA test for no significant reason other than to support my husband and this is what I discovered. And I did mention, you know, if I am the product of assault, I want you to know, I, I would never blame you.
[00:23:50] Doe: I completely understand. Sort of touched on all of those aspects of what, sort of, I had thought maybe was my backstory. And, I waited, and I waited, and I waited, and it was several minutes before a response, and the response came across, when can we talk?
[00:24:09] Alexis: Mm.
[00:24:10] Doe: And that was it. And so it was a couple of days later, when I was able to have some time, which I knew I would need a fair amount of, to have this conversation that we agreed to talk.
[00:24:23] Doe: And In that conversation, I told her the story, I laid it all out for her, everything. I told her who my biological father was, that I had figured out who it, well, who he was, and she said, I’m sure you have, because you are able to do those kinds of things, so I’m sure you have. And I told her I needed to know my story.
[00:24:45] Doe: How did I come into this world? My mother was so absolutely devastated by this information. She had a nervous breakdown. was hospitalized because my mother didn’t know either.
[00:25:00] Alexis: Oh my gosh.
[00:25:03] Alexis: So She was not hiding anything from you.
[00:25:06] Doe: my mother was not hiding, well, she was, but she wasn’t hiding the fact that she knew my
[00:25:12] Alexis: Oh, that’s true. Okay. Yes. So she was not being truthful not having had sex when she got pregnant with you, but she fully believed that your birth certificate father was your father.
[00:25:28] Doe: She absolutely believed it. And so I knew in that moment that she was telling me the truth, that she did truly believe that he, that my birth certificate father was my biological father. And. So, here we are, both in the same sort of crazy situation, but we’re on totally different trajectories with it. She’s now discovering the truth about a child that she carried.
[00:25:55] Doe: And raised that she believed was the child of one person. So she was going through all of that sort of feeling of betrayal and feeling of, of almost violation. Which I could understand completely, thinking you, you had one man’s child and it turned out to be someone else’s. And also she was struggling with the idea that this truth, the truth would come out.
[00:26:21] Doe: And what it would do to her life if it did. And so she told me the story of my conception. Obviously her past was not as, as innocent as she had hoped that she could portray it to be. And essentially what she, without going into too many details about it she essentially told me that she couldn’t believe she didn’t get pregnant before she did with a child, that she had been going into bars and being served since she was 14 years old.
[00:26:49] Doe: And that I was the product of a drunken one night stand that she really can’t recall.
[00:26:55] Alexis: How did you feel when you learned that information?
[00:26:59] Doe: I felt like a dirty little secret. That, that I knew immediately I was not going to be able to reach out to my biological father. I knew right away given her response that this was not, you know, this was going to be something I knew she was going to ask me not to do because it, you know, tell as little people as possible.
[00:27:23] Doe: She was upset with me that I told my husband and I said, well, he’s my husband and we live together. I cannot keep this from him. I was, it was totally devastating. I cried every day. I, you know, I was upset finding out about that, you know, this man wasn’t my father, despite the fact that we had no relationship with one another still.
[00:27:47] Doe: His family has a very long history German and Irish descent and so he and his family were very proud of their Irish descent. St. Patrick’s Day was a holiday in our family and, you know, just all of the, that cultural impact. I wore a clad owl ring. Because I identified as an Irish American, because our family was very proud of their Irish heritage.
[00:28:11] Doe: I have been a professional singer for most of my life, and my paternal grandmother was a singer. So clearly this is where you get your musical ability from. All of the things I’ve been told my whole life, this is where this comes from, you’re proud to be who you are, where did this all come from then?
[00:28:30] Doe: Clearly, I did not get my voice from her and am I Irish? I don’t know. I have no idea. And so it was a real turning upside down of my whole life. Looking at my children and thinking, you know, he’s not their grandfather. Some stranger is their grandfather. And when I put the photo of my biological father here.
[00:28:57] Doe: At 18, against the picture of my oldest child, who was in his mid twenties at the time. They are each other’s doppelganger, like, looks exactly like him. I have a nephew, through my half sister, who looks just like my second son. So the genes are very strong. And so looking those kids in the face and, and telling them, you know, here’s the thing, who you think your grandfather is, is not your grandfather, and he’s not my father.
[00:29:27] Doe: And this is what I’m sort of struggling with right now. And, you know, there, it’s interesting how people can be a step removed from a, from a crisis or a trauma and can sort of help you bring it into perspective a little bit. Their thought was really, Mom, are you okay? How are you? This really doesn’t affect us necessarily, but wow, if we were you, this is, we’d feel devastated.
[00:29:53] Alexis: Did they have a relationship with your birth certificate father, or did this change much for them in terms of, you know, their relationship? Mm
[00:30:03] Doe: Um, so, I’ve been in Arizona since they were 2 and 4 years old. So they’ve grown up away from that, that part of their family. You know, occasional phone calls, video chats, the visit here or there, but there definitely wasn’t a close relationship there with any of my family on that side because of the distance.
[00:30:24] Alexis: Okay. Wow. So you are just dealing with so much turmoil and feeling completely uprooted and your mom does not want you to tell anyone, but it sounds like you, obviously you told your husband, he’s your, he’s your rock there. And then you tell your children, who else do you tell when you have this kind of push from your mom not to disclose.
[00:30:52] Doe: Well, it was tough to decide who to tell and who not to tell, because clearly this was affecting my day to day existence. And so friends were aware something was very wrong, and so it was difficult to know how much to reveal, how much to say and, and whether to say anything at all.
[00:31:10] Alexis: So what do you do?
[00:31:12] Doe: So I found a therapist and I started seeing a counselor. In my past, I’d always sort of, you know, dealt with things emotionally on my own. I never really thought that I needed professional help, but boy, this was huge. And I knew I couldn’t burden my husband and my children with trying to help me because they had no idea where to even begin.
[00:31:33] Doe: I had no idea where to begin. So I got a rough recommendation for a counselor who I started seeing weekly. This was a very interesting case for her. She’d never really heard about non parent expected events and DNA surprises. And so it was new for her, sort of new groundbreaking for her and her colleagues.
[00:31:55] Doe: And so they were all sort of, Taking an interest in my case and really the, and where was I coming from, emotionally and mentally. And they were sort of, creating a template for how to help the other people like me, who may present for their services. And if it was not for my therapist, I, I’m not sure where I would be right now.
[00:32:16] Doe: So she gave me a safe place to really talk about all of my feelings, about everything, about my father and about my mother and my dysfunctional relationship with them and my. and my adulthood and how all of this has affected who I am as a person. And how is this now going to also impact me and my future, what I have discovered?
[00:32:40] Doe: it was a long road of self exploration and self discovery and of learning to forgive and And to learn to accept what you cannot change. My therapist called it radical acceptance.
[00:32:54] Alexis: Oh, yes. We talk about that all the time on this podcast and at the retreats and yes, radical acceptance is how we get through, right?
[00:33:06] Doe: That’s the only way.
[00:33:08] Alexis: Does your father know? Does your dad know? Or have you held this secret?
[00:33:13] Doe: No, he does not know. I have a sister that I grew up with who is six years younger than me. She does not know. My mother has just sworn me to secrecy. And so, why I have to be anonymous when I, when I interview. Because I am protecting, she’s asked me to protect her and I, for now, have. Decided that I will do that.
[00:33:35] Alexis: So I know that therapy is, is helping you. How are you coping with holding on to the secret? And how is that affecting you?
[00:33:43] Doe: Well, it’s made me feel freer, oddly enough. I’d always felt growing up that I was not where I was supposed to be. And I’m sure you hear that a hundred times over. You always feel like you don’t fit. Like you’re the oddball. And, you know, even when your parents are pointing it out to you. You know, we just don’t understand where you come from.
[00:34:05] Doe: I was the first person in my family to go to college. I actually have two degrees. I was the first person to become a professional musician in my family, even though there were people with musical ability. I just always sort of had this go get em sort of attitude about life. And everyone else was very much, I’m going to stay in this, Town in upstate New York and not leave.
[00:34:25] Doe: This is all I want to know about. I don’t want to know about anything else.
[00:34:28] Alexis: Mm hmm.
[00:34:29] Doe: so I really felt a lot of freedom after a while because boy, this explains a lot, doesn’t it? It really helped me to see, you’re right, you don’t belong in this situation.
[00:34:41] Doe: And there’s a reason why you don’t belong here. And this is the best reason of all. Like, it’s actually in your DNA that you don’t belong. And you’re just fine. Channeling who you are, nature versus nurture, and all of the things, clearly there’s something there for nature. Because once I was able to delve a little bit further into my biological family, I started to get answers to my questions.
[00:35:07] Alexis: Yeah, that is so fascinating how you’ve been able to use your expertise to find out so much information and you still have not contacted your biological father, is that correct?
[00:35:21] Doe: That’s correct.
[00:35:22] Alexis: Do you want to? Mm
[00:35:25] Doe: um, however, I’m not at a point where I feel like I would be willing to accept the fallout from it, the potential fallout. You know, you get into these situations where, you know, you’re trying to keep something secret. And the more people that even have an inkling about it, it causes anxiety about potentially something getting out.
[00:35:49] Doe: And so my situation is a bit unique because I’m from a rather small area. The sister that I grew up with and the sister that I didn’t grow up with went to school together and were in the same grade.
[00:36:05] Alexis: Oh, wow. Okay.
[00:36:07] Doe: So, my half sisters know each other. They’re actually friends on social media.
[00:36:13] Alexis: Oh my gosh. Okay, so you’re really kind of just sitting back and watching that.
[00:36:20] Doe: Yes it, it, there’s other connections as well, which are a bit complicated to explain without, like, a diagram, but there’s a couple of different ways that it, it sort of hits really close, if I were to reach out to my biological father and talk to him. Let him know my existence and my son’s existence.
[00:36:39] Doe: And if he were to say to me, I want to introduce you to the family. I want to have you be a part of things. I would be unable to do that because my half brother and sister know who I am. We, we live in a very small area. My sister that I did not grow up with her husband has known me since childhood.
[00:37:02] Alexis: Oh my gosh. Wow.
[00:37:05] Doe: came out to my bio father and he introduced me to the family, this man is going to say, there’s no what this isn’t your father,
[00:37:15] Alexis: Yeah.
[00:37:16] Doe: father. He’s been your father my whole life. Well, he actually hasn’t been. So,
[00:37:22] Alexis: I feel like I’m feeling anxious just hearing this and all of the, the close connections and you know, it’s like you’re, you’re like on a razor’s edge, right, of, of proximity to these people.
[00:37:36] Doe: For sure. There’s no six degrees of separation here. It’s maybe one or two and that’s it.
[00:37:41] Alexis: So in your ancestry results, did you toggle it so that people can’t match with you?
[00:37:48] Alexis: Is there a concern about, the siblings you grew up with taking the test and seeing that you’re half siblings or somebody else finding you?
[00:37:56] Doe: So there was but I was able to disguise my identity on Ancestry so you can use like an alias, as far as when people are looking at any information you have on Ancestry, instead of my name being attached to it, it will be my alias attached to it, which is like, it’s sort of a code name that you can use.
[00:38:15] Doe: Some people just use their initials for their Ancestry account, so that nobody can figure out who they are that way to keep their things private. So I just switched everything over to an alias and I you know, named my tree, DNA Family Tree. Keep it all very sort of benign. And of course, anybody that’s living in the tree is not visible to other people looking at your tree, even if you make it public, your living people are not shown.
[00:38:43] Doe: And so, if, say, one of my half siblings through my biological father were to test, they’re going to match to me, but they’re not going to be able to get too much from my tree, except to see past, like, like to the grandparents level. That’s about as far as they’d be able to actually see. So, my biological father has two brothers as well.
[00:39:07] Doe: And so, I felt pretty confident that, given how much time it took me to figure out, To do the whole genetic genealogy thing and figure out how to work all of that. Someone without that background just logging in and looking at their DNA might not go that far to say, I’m going to try to figure out who this is.
[00:39:25] Doe: And I have had matches come along since then through my biological father. And what I’m discovering is that there are a lot of what I call disenfranchised children from this family. So there’s people out there that are testing because they don’t have a connection to their family. And they are part of my paternal family. So there’s a group of five men one of them being I matched to his daughter. On Ancestry. She’s the one who told me my dad is adopted and we did this test to see if we could figure out who his parents are.
[00:40:02] Doe: What I discovered was is that he had four half brothers. All of them shared the same mother, who is a cousin of my biological father.
[00:40:13] Alexis: Okay.
[00:40:14] Doe: all five of them were raised either in foster care or were given up for adoption and didn’t know about one another.
[00:40:22] Alexis: Mmm.
[00:40:23] Doe: So I was able to bring five brothers together.
[00:40:25] Alexis: Okay, I was going to ask, did you make a connection there? Wow.
[00:40:30] Doe: to identify all of their biological fathers for them.
[00:40:34] Alexis: That’s incredible. And do they now have like a relationship?
[00:40:38] Doe: So they are all now, you know, in contact with each other and going over memories and seeing some of them are seeing photographs of family members for the first time.
[00:40:47] Doe: This is her biological mother. This is your biological father, you know, so it’s been a really great experience for all of them. And I find myself being surrounded by people who are all having really good experiences with their DNA. And I find myself at the center of that storm and a position of not, not having the same.
[00:41:09] Doe: Same experience as them.
[00:41:10] Alexis: Yeah. So you, you kind of are at this point, You’ve told the people that you’ve told, and you are now anonymously kind of moving through this space. Where would you say you are now with everything, and what do you hope for next?
[00:41:29] Doe: I feel like I’m in a reasonably good spot now. I, I can talk about this without crying. So that’s what I always thought. That was really great. The first time I was able to have a discussion about this with someone and I didn’t spend the whole time in tears that I felt was a good sign that I had reached a good point where I can talk about it and it still hurts, but I have a handle on it.
[00:41:52] Doe: But I find a lot of healing in helping others. Because I know how I felt when I had that realization that this man is not my father, then who is? And I, when I put myself into someone else’s shoes who may be like me, who didn’t feel like they could reach out to their mother immediately and find out what was going on or just wants to sort of figure it out on their own without pulling the other people in.
[00:42:18] Doe: How can I help them? Because I know if I wasn’t able to help myself, I would have went crazy. Because I needed that information, it gave me something to focus on and something to channel that pain and anxiety through to find my truth. And I know how reassuring that can feel to find it.
[00:42:37] Doe: It starts a whole other cascade of emotions and feelings. Once you figure it out. That’s not the end. It’s not the end. And I think that anyone who’s been through this, I don’t know, maybe a few would agree with me, but there’s always another question. There’s always another piece of information you want to know.
[00:42:53] Doe: And no matter how much information you find out, will it ever be enough?
[00:42:58] Alexis: Yes. Yes, that’s something that we’ve definitely talked about. And the fact that You kind of sometimes have to make peace with the fact that you will never, that radical acceptance, that you will never have all of the answers to the puzzle. And that’s kind of just how it is, right? Like you can, you can get a ton of answers, especially if people are alive and they’re willing to talk, but there’s always, like you said, there’s always something that pops up and you have to weigh the relationships in your life and if you’re willing to put those at risk and just all of the things that you touched on.
[00:43:34] Alexis: So you’ve really turned your experience into helping other people Are you now seeing more of these DNA surprises and NPEs your work?
[00:43:46] Doe: It’s very interesting that My working with my colleague it got a lot of the other people at my job interested in their heritage and their genealogy and their background. And I’ve had several people at work approach me and say, my results are in, can you take a look at them? Because something’s weird.
[00:44:04] Doe: And so I have helped several people figure out a friend of mine at work is currently looking for a half sister. That is 18 years older than her. She was unaware that she had a sister that was 18 years older than her. And so, with my help, she did the DNA test, and we are now actively searching for her half sister who is placed for adoption.
[00:44:28] Alexis: Well I think it’s so beautiful that you are helping other people in these situations and I can’t imagine the level of empathy, well I guess I can because I’ve been through it too, but you know, the level of empathy that you’re able to provide because you’ve gone through these experiences and these emotions and had these questions come up and I think, you know, there are.
[00:44:54] Alexis: You are wonderful people doing wonderful work in this space helping people find their families. I think the fact that you are also an NPE is really impactful though for people that are going through this experience, so thank you for the work that you’re doing.
[00:45:10] Doe: I appreciate that.
[00:45:11] Alexis: Yeah, now I do want to touch on your podcast.
[00:45:16] Alexis: So, Doe is going to launch a podcast soon that’s going to dive more into the DNA Surprise world and also the genealogical aspects of it. Is that right?
[00:45:31] Doe: Yes, that’s correct.
[00:45:32] Alexis: Can you tell us more about it?
[00:45:34] Doe: Yeah so the podcast is gonna be called Decoded, Secrets of the Family. the beginning of it is going to be, I’m going to be having some of the people that I’ve helped. I’m going to be interviewing them and having them tell their story, much like I’m doing today. And then sort of put in there the mix of, then I found out who I really was.
[00:45:53] Doe: And this is how I did it. This is who helped me. Whether it was me or a search angel or any number of people out there who have the ability and the skill to, to help people find their truth. And it’s, It seems like maybe all the stories might sound the same at some point, but once I started talking about my story and listening to other people’s stories, I found there’s commonality, but there’s also some really huge differences in people’s stories.
[00:46:20] Doe: There’s always a unique part to it. Always the gotcha moment that maybe no one was expecting. And so, My hope is, is that people will, who have had these DNA surprises and who are wanting help to look for their truth that my podcast will help them do that. And, and maybe they’ll pay it forward as well.
[00:46:42] Alexis: Yeah, that’s amazing. I think the more people with the skill set that you have, the better. I feel like that is on my bucket list, is to learn more about this. And Doe and I live in the same town, so I might just be knocking on her door and asking for some tutorials on how to walk through and do it.
[00:47:03] Doe: Well, it sounds like we could learn from each other because I had never done a podcast before. So,
[00:47:09] Alexis: Perfect, perfect.
[00:47:11] Alexis: do you have for a parent who might be keeping a DNA surprise from their child?
[00:47:19] Doe: You know, my advice is probably hard advice, but you need to be honest with your child. The devastation that comes from finding it out any other way is really destabilizing. It really causes people to question their whole identity, their whole life. Woulda, coulda, shoulda. You know, me with my not so great relationship with my birth certificate father.
[00:47:47] Doe: Of course. Those questions have come up. What would my life have been like if this other man had raised me, what things would have been better, what things might’ve been worse, you know? So be honest and give them the information that they’re asking for that they need. Because finding it out from ancestry.
[00:48:02] Doe: com or finding it out from a, a relative who might know who, you know, gets loose lipped, or this is not the way that somebody should find out. Maybe they don’t have the whole truth about who they are.
[00:48:17] Alexis: Thank you for sharing that. And what advice do you have for someone who just uncovered a DNA surprise, like being an NPE?
[00:48:28] Doe: First thing is find somebody you can talk to, internalizing how you’re feeling is going to chew you up and spit you out. Needing to find somebody you can talk with. Not even necessarily who has any type of counseling expertise or even with DNA surprises. Just someone who you trust, who can listen to what you’re saying, who can help give you, sort of like that same advice my husband gave me, help sort of simplify it, help you see the forest through the trees.
[00:48:55] Doe: What is it exactly I’m upset about, and what is it I want to know? And sometimes friends, people can help you tease out what it is you’re feeling, and what it is you need to know. And from there, maybe find a good counselor, and find somebody that knows how to do genetic genealogy who can help you figure it out.
[00:49:17] Alexis: Doe, thank you so much for coming on the podcast and sharing your story. I love talking to people who have taken this very difficult experience and then used their own experience to help others. It’s so inspiring to hear the work that you’re doing. And for anyone who’s listening, I will be sure to put Doe’s new podcast, In the show notes when it launches.
[00:49:45] Alexis: Thanks again for joining me.
[00:49:48] Doe: I appreciate it. Thank you.